From The Writing Cave

Sometimes I Don’t Love My Characters

June 1, 2021

Sometimes I don’t love my characters. There I said it. I have admitted the thing no author ever admits.

It never starts out that way. I always love my characters in the beginning. They’re all bright and shiny and new. They are fun. As I write and I get to know them better, sometimes they become a bit…bossy. Let me explain.

I always start out with an idea of where I want to go with the story. I plot a few (very few) points that I want to hit with my story, and I go forth and write. Things go along smoothly for the most part until a character…acts up. They suddenly pull a hard left, and I have no idea what they’re doing.

That whole dancing bar scene in Break and Enter? Never supposed to happen. Dani being afraid of water in Hit and Run? I had no clue until I was writing the scene with her and Gage at the docks, and she wouldn’t get out of the Jeep. Cain from Coast Guard RECON being born with a different name? News to me. Don’t even get me started on the characters in the Lock & Key series. They just did whatever the heck they wanted. All. The. Time.

Okay, I know what you’re thinking. Yes, I am the writer, and theoretically, I have control over my characters. But, in reality? It doesn’t work that way. When I try to stop my characters from doing certain things or force my characters to do other things, my characters stop talking to me. They clam up tighter than a jar lid that's been in the dishwasher too many times, and no amount of coaxing gets them to budge.

I guess my subconscious has a plan that my conscious mind hasn't been briefed on. It's part of the creative process, but I have to tell you, sometimes it's damned inconvenient. If my characters would just do what I asked, writing would be so much easier.

Then again, maybe that's exactly the problem. The characters who behave are the ones nobody remembers. The ones who hijack the plot, refuse to get out of the Jeep, or show up with a secret identity I never approved? Those are the ones readers fall in love with. So I suppose I'll keep letting them run the show. Somebody around here has to be in charge, and clearly, it's not me.